|
The public hearing was held today (5/27) regarding the Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for Black Range Minerals (BRM). BRM opened with a presentation that was followed by several hours of public comments. For the most part, both sides were very civil and respectful of each other's viewpoints. At the end of the public hearing, the Commisssioners posed several questions to BRM and decided to table a decision on the CUP until their next meeting on June 9th. The Commissioners did not give an indication of how they would end up voting on this issue. Thank you to all the members of TAC that particiapted in the public hearing. They did an excellent job presenting our issues to the Commissioners. Also, thanks to support of our many members that attended the meeting. It was a very long meeting for all involved. If nothing else, we showed how much we care about the safety and welfare of our community! Kevin Mendenhall Several articles from the hearing (some that are very one-sided) are included below.
Fremont County board delays vote on uranium mining THE GAZETTE CAÑON CITY - An eighthour hearing Tuesday wasn't long enough for Fremont County commissioners to rule on a request to drill for uranium in the northwest part of the county.
After hearing comments from more than 70 people, the board delayed a vote until June 9 on the permit request by Australia-based Black Range Minerals.
"During the day, I've changed my mind several times from information we've had," said Commissioner Larry Lasha.
The Tallahassee Creek area was drilled extensively for uranium through the early 1980s, until the price collapsed.
Black Range Minerals wants to pick it back up and drill 800 holes on 8,169 acres.
With a resurgence of nuclear power worldwide and uranium selling for about $70 a pound - up tenfold from five years ago - companies are racing to mine Colorado, which has the third-largest stores of uranium in the nation.
Black Range, the first company in recent years to seek an exploration permit here, has spent $1 million on the project, and some ranch owners hope to turn a profit by allowing drilling on their land.
Other residents, most of whom bought land for retirement homes in the mountains, see the drilling as a threat to their water, property values and rural way of life.
"Everything I've acquired in my life, minus one divorce, is on that 3.1 acres and the house I built. Now it appears to be worthless," said resident Jeff Dewell.
"Knowing mineral rights are important, we paid more for our property," said Richard Boyer, owner of one of the ranches where drilling is proposed. "Now, because of special interest groups, our mineral rights may be taken away without compensation."
Black Range managing director Michael Haynes said the U.S. imports most of the uranium it uses for nuclear energy, and domestic production is the key to energy independence.
"We can't pick and choose where uranium resources are found. The western U.S. is blessed and very fortunate to host these uranium resources," Haynes said. Publish Date: 5/28/2008 Page: A6 Analysis: Drilling could give economic boom to area Debbie Bell The Daily Record If given the green light, uranium exploration drilling in the Tallahassee area eventually could lead to an economic boom in Fremont County. Mike Haynes, managing director of Black Range Minerals, recently detailed potential benefits the county stands to reap, including improved roads, communication and emergency services, as well as increased employment, wages and property taxes to the county. An Economic Impact Analysis of the Black Range Minerals Taylor Ranch Project by Rochette Consulting indicates if the project comes to fruition, as many as 437 jobs, more than $10 million in direct earnings and almost $105 million in total earnings could be realized annually from 2011 through 2018. Added to smaller earnings between now and 2010, the Taylor Ranch Project eventually could have more than a $1 billion earnings impact. The project also could add more than $4 million to the county’s coffers through sales tax and personal property tax revenues; almost $5 million in sales tax revenues to Cañon City and Florence; and $1.5 million to the Cañon City School District. “This Conditional Use Permit goes well beyond the concerns of the local people,” Haynes told the Fremont County Commissioners during Tuesday’s public hearing. “We want to work with the local neighborhood. We don’t want to work against it.” Black Range Minerals is seeking the CUP to determine the economic viability of the uranium deposits located in the county through an exploration drilling phase that could last between three and five years. “Results will stack up during that time,” Haynes said during an informational gathering in March. “Our tests indicate there is considerable mineralization there. We will determine how consistent that mineralization is. The more information we get, the better decisions we can make.” If exploration results were positive, Black Range then would apply for permission to mine and work its way through a complicated series of literally dozens of required state and county permits. If a separate mining permit eventually was issued, Black Range could move more than half a million tons of uranium ore per year. If each step was successful, Haynes said BRM would invest time, money and effort to create the most technologically-advanced, state-of-the-art facilities possible, including its own mill to process the uranium. Black Range hopes to take advantage of a “world class uranium district” in the Tallahassee area. The vicinity is rich with mining history and has been home to 16 uranium mines throughout the years, before the bottom dropped out of the uranium industry in the 1980s and prices plummeted. Haynes said uranium prices have risen substantially since 2004, from $15 to $68 per pound, explaining the current resurgence in uranium exploration. “If the Taylor Project is not viable now, it is highly unlikely we ever would return to the project,” Haynes said. Even if that was the final result, Haynes said, Black Range Minerals would submit its exploration results to the county or any other company interested in uranium mining there. “We want to minimize the impact on the community,” Haynes said. Publish Date: 5/28/2008 Page: A6
No decision yet
Debbie Bell The Daily Record Almost seven hours of testimony Tuesday overwhelmed the Fremont County Commissioners with so much information on proposed uranium exploration in the Tallahassee area that they tabled a permit decision until next month. “This is not unexpected,” Mike Haynes, managing director of Black Range Minerals, said following the board’s unanimous vote. “There was a vast amount of information that was discussed today, and this is perfectly reasonable.” Black Range Minerals is seeking a Conditional Use Permit to drill about 800 test holes on 3,900 acres, primarily on the Taylor and Boyer ranches. The Australian company hopes to discover whether the “world class uranium district” holds the promise of a commercially-viable mining project. Controversy swirled and accusations filled the air as 70 people strode to the microphone, one after another. Speakers were evenly divided with half siding with ranch owners’ rights to develop their property and the other half vehemently opposed to the project as proposed. Independent Experts A panel of independent subject-matter experts also took the stand to provide authoritative information on a wide range of community concerns, including water, reclamation, property values and radiation. Haynes opened the hearing by explaining the United States is the world’s largest nuclear consumer. The nation currently imports 95 percent of the required uranium and holds only 3 percent of the world’s uranium resources in finite locations. “We cannot pick and choose where the uranium resources are found,” Haynes said. Haynes said because the 3,900-acre exploration site is enclosed within 8,169 acres, a large buffer zone would help protect neighbors from the nuisances of noise and light. He also explained state property rights law. “Owners of mineral rights have the legal right to explore for and extract their minerals,” Haynes said. Groundwater Protection Susan Wyman, a water hydrologist and civil engineer from La Veta, described an aggressive groundwater protection plan to prevent aquifer cross communication, while Steve Brown of Centennial, health physicist and specialist in radiologic science, unraveled myths about radiation. “There is more radioactivity in smoke alarms than in a typical uranium ore hole,” Brown said. “Uranium ore is not a hazardous material.” Brown cited numerous professional references and said people who smoke an average of 1.5 packs a day receive 1,300 times more radiation than a uranium worker throughout a one-year span. He said naturally-occurring radiation is so prevalent, exploration drilling is like throwing a glass of water into a lake. Gary Tuttle, landscape architect, reassured the crowd the project will not generate traffic congestion in the area. He also said, based on other uranium activity throughout the state, housing values will not fall but instead could dramatically rise. Big Guns Both sides brought out the big guns. The Colorado Mining Association, a 132-year-old trade association, stood up for Black Range while the Western Mining Action Network, a legal group based in Durango, opposed the project. With so many speakers on the agenda, most tried to stay on track and to the point. “Your rights end where my nose begins,” said Tallahassee area resident Patrick Caulfield, as he urged the board to deny the permit. “Compatible and harmonious? Well, if it was, you wouldn’t have all these people here.” Beverly Cain owns 145 acres in the area where she plans to retire with her husband and create an income-generating ranch. She traveled from California to oppose the exploration. “Now, my property is worthless,” Cain said. “To ignore these concerns is intolerable. We will be forced to literally walk away from our property. You have the duty to protect the health, safety and well-being of our community.” Duty to be Informed However, for every opponent who voiced an opinion, an advocate was waiting in the wings. Diane Taylor, a member of the ranching family that hopes to develop the mineral rights, said it was a property buyer’s duty to be informed on land before they make the purchase. “Did any of these people do any research about the area where they were planning to spend the rest of their lives?” Taylor asked. “Fifteen years ago, when we saw a car coming up County Road 2, I put the coffee on because I knew we had company coming. No longer.” Taylor said the recent subdivision boom in the area has meant thousands more construction vehicles on the very roads opponents to the exploration seek to protect. “It is a real possibility we will have to subdivide our ranch in the near future,” Taylor said, if the uranium exploration is not allowed to proceed. That many additional homes in the area would create another set of concerns. Energy Crisis Many spoke about the current energy crisis, the relief uranium can offer and the need to lead the way into the future. “Fremont County may be able to make a contribution to energy dependence,” said Tom Pool, mining engineer and landowner who supported Black Range. “Let’s find out.” In the end, the input proved to be too cumbersome for the commissioners to handle in a single day. With regular session and additional discussion, the marathon session lasted almost nine hours. “I thought earlier this morning I’d be ready to make a decision,” said District 3 Commissioner Ed Norden. “Given the volume of the reports we’ve been given today, I’m not ready to make a decision other than to table it to a later date.” Difficult Decision Commission Chairman Larry Lasha said the decision was difficult because everyone involved had so much at stake. “I know I’ve changed my mind several times throughout the course of the day,” Lasha said. “It’s been a long day with a lot of input.” The commissioners will again take up the issue during their next regularly scheduled meeting but will not accept further communication on the record because the public hearing was officially closed. The meeting will begin at 9:30 a.m. June 9 at the Fremont County Administration Building, 615 Macon Ave. The date was moved up one day because of a Colorado Counties Inc. meeting. Debbie Bell may be reached at
This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
|